Laws of Attraction: Can conservative value investors love venture capital too? In a word, absolutely.
A few years ago, my Harvard Business School classmate, Len Batterson, reached out to me to pitch his venture capital firm. I’d never before thought about investing in venture capital. But the background material he shared was intriguing. The funds he has led have had a great track record, delivering an average annual return of 28% over the past 30+ years.
Can conservative value investors love venture capital, too? In a word, absolutely. Case in point: I’m a conservative value investor, a “belt-and-suspenders” type. I like value stocks and dividends. I manage asset allocation carefully and don’t look for windfalls. For me, good enough is indeed good enough.
So why have I invested in venture capital? Sound inconsistent? I don’t think so.
Let's Back up a Bit
I’m 70, semi-retired, and an accredited investor based on our net worth. So we’re comfortable, but we’re not rich enough to get hit by the Federal Estate Tax. That is, unless we get very lucky or Congress reduces the exemption level.
I’m also the analytic and strategic type. Asset allocation is important to me. Despite my conservative nature, I try to invest some money in more aggressive growth vehicles.
So, I discussed the opportunity with my financial adviser. Since, at the time, he was with a major brokerage firm, he could not make any money selling such an investment. Despite that, he encouraged our jumping in. He felt our asset allocation was too conservative and urged we be a little more aggressive. Venture capital fit that bill. According to the Cambridge Associates Global Venture Capital Index, the industry over the past ten years has generated average annual returns of 15%, with the top half of all firms delivering returns averaging 22%.
Our Asset Allocation Was Too Conservative and Needed Alternative Investment Help
Our advisor further explained that venture capital is an “alternative investment.” It doesn’t have a strong correlation with stocks or bonds. Adding some venture capital to our investment mix should help smooth the ups and downs of our stock and bond portfolios, he said. That should reduce our total portfolio risk, despite the riskiness of each individual venture capital deal, as long as we diversify enough within this asset class. After our initial modest investment, our adviser suggested we invest more. That would enable greater venture capital diversification, and we have followed his advice.
(Full disclosure: I have been doing some part-time advisory work for VCapital LLC, an extension of Batterson’s earlier venture capital firm, for the past few years, but I hadn’t yet made a dime from him before committing to investment.)
Still Clinging to My Conservative Value Orientation
Now for some cautions. Venture capital is not liquid. Don’t invest money into VC that you may need in the next 5-7 years. In fact, don’t invest money in venture capital that you can’t afford to lose.
While historical returns are terrific, and there’s no reason why they won’t remain so, venture capital is risky. Several years ago The Wall Street Journal reported that roughly three quarters of ventures fail. On average, though, the big winners more than offset the losers. Even so, I’ll never invest more than 5% of my net worth in venture capital. That will be diversified across several deals, offered by firms I trust. I AM a conservative value investor.
Implementing a Value Strategy in Venture Capital
I trust Batterson’s approach to venture capital. It represents a value approach to this aggressive asset class that fits my nature.
His team does LOTS of homework and invests only in deals with exceptional potential. They won’t all be winners, but his team’s long-term batting average – 37% of his deals have made money- is double the industry average.
The team focuses on early stage deals, before valuations are bid up in later stage deals. That means lower venture valuations and an opportunity for higher returns. The team also focuses on opportunities in the Midwest. The Midwest has fewer venture capital firms and fewer investor dollars chasing deals than in Silicon Valley or other venture capital hot spots. That too means lower venture valuations and so better deals.
That’s how I maintain my value orientation, as a staunch investment conservative even in the often wild world of venture capital investing.
We would be happy to hear what you think. Talk to us.
Other articles you might like
To See and Not See
How do top performing venture capitalists succeed when historical data shows that most venture capital investments lose?
VCapital at Middle Age
Six years since our first investment in Intensity Therapeutics, VCapital is invested in eleven companies today. Having reached our middle age in “venture capital years,” we are growing increasingly optimistic about our prospects for ultimate maturity.
Reflections on a Career in Venture Capital
A career in venture capital requires an ongoing need to learn and keep learning. After almost four decades in, Len Batterson shares his experience and investment stories.